Friday, February 21, 2025

The invention Of Hebrew, Seth L. Sanders, c. 2009

The Invention Of Hebrew, Seth L. Sanders, c. 2009.

Author: assistant professor of religion at Trinity College and the editor of the Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions. Trinity College, Hartford, CT. 

This is going to be very "heavy reading" for me.

Preface

Introduction

Chapter 1
Modernity's Ghosts: The Bible as Political Communication

 

Thesis: Bible criticism -- text seen as text. In fact, the author argues, early criticism lost sight of what the texts were about; to whom were they addressed; what was their purpose?

 

Chapter 2

Wednesday, February 19, 2025

Who Really Wrote The [Hebrew] Bible: The Story of the Scribes, William M. Schniedewind, c. 2024. Princeton University Press.

Who Really Wrote The [Hebrew] Bible: The Story of the Scribes, William M. Schniedewind, c. 2024. Princeton University Press.

Professor of Biblical Studies at UCLA, where he was the inaugural holder of the Kershaw Chair of Ancient Eastern Mediterranean Studies. Has written at least two other books on the Bible. 

Kuntillet 'Ajrud inscriptions, link here.

Kuntillet ʿAjrud or Horvat Teman is a late 9th/early 8th centuries BCE site in the northeast part of the Sinai Peninsula.
It is frequently described as a shrine, though this is not certain.
The Kuntillet Ajrud inscriptions discovered in the excavations are significant in biblical archaeology. Kuntillet Ajrud is in the north Sinai; carbon-14 dating indicates occupation from 801–770 BCE, and the eponymous texts may have been written c. 800 BCE. [Interesting enough, this corresponds almost exactly to Homer's Iliad and Odyssey.]
As a perennial water source in this arid region, it constituted an important station on an ancient trade route connecting the Gulf of Aqaba (an inlet of the Red Sea) and the Mediterranean. It was located only 50 kilometers from the major oasis of Kadesh Barnea.
Additionally, despite its proximity to the Kingdom of Judah, it has an association with the northern Kingdom of Israel (Samaria): "elements of the material culture such as the pottery, the 'northern' orthography in certain inscriptions, and reference to YHWH of Samaria suggest that Kuntillet ʿAjrud was an Israelite outpost, or at the very least, had a strong Israelite presence".

Northeast Sinai! How close to Gaza?  One can locate is on google maps. Type in Kuntillet 'Ajrud and google will automatically change is to Khirbet el-Qom, about twenty miles due east of the northeast corner of the Gaza Strip. It is about five miles west of Hebron. Bethlehem is about five miles south of Jerusalem and another ten miles south takes one to Hebron.

Nice short preface.

Introduction.

Scribal communities, not individuals are important. 

It was a Hellenistic idea that "individuals" wrote the Bible.

The DocumentaryHypothesis

"A wisdom school." A genre of literature called "wisdom literature" which the author feels does not exist.

Author "defines" his view of Jerusalem, Judah, and Israel, p. 5.

The writing of the Bible? All roads lead to Jerusalem.


Beginning of the Iron Age -- 11th century BCE -- p. 7 - 8. That also aligns with the end of the Bronze Age, with the fall of Troy -- Bronze Age transitioning to the Iron Age -- said to have occurred about 1200 BC. Wiki: 

The Iron Age ( c. 1200 – c. 550 BC) is the final epoch of the three historical Metal Ages, after the Chalcolithic and Bronze Age.

The focus of this book: scribal communities. 

Chapter 1: Scribes and Their Apprentices -- Communities At Work

 

Tuesday, February 18, 2025

The World According To Garp, John Irving

The World According To Garp, John Irving, c. 1976.

Chapter 1: Boston Mercy

Garp's mother, Jenny Fields, Boston, arrested in 1942.

Fields, family fortune in shoes.

Fields, a nurse, looking for a husband to have a baby. 

TSgt Garp, "the late gunner" -- violent death -- a nose gunner in the B-17C; and, a waist gunner int he B-17E before they made him a ball turret gunner.

35th flight over France.

Injured. Brought to Boston Mercy where Jenny Fields was working. 

Baby: T. S. Garp. Technical Sergeant Garp.

Father dies.

The book is about the son, t. S. Garp.

Chapter Two: Blood and Blue

Humorous, puns. Clever writing. Almost too clever by half. 

Fields now a school nurse at Steering School.

800 boys; a boy school.

Jenny Fields signed a 5-year contract; great nurse.

Story of Garp getting lost on the roof trying to capture pigeons.

p. 45 

Really a fun book to read. 

Not sure yet what to think of it, especially knowing that some lists have this book as a top literature book. There needs to be a lesson by the end of the book.


 


Saturday, February 15, 2025

The Brontës: Wild Genius On The Moor: The Story Of A Literary Family -- Juliet Barker

The Brontës: Wild Genius On The Moor: The Story Of A Literary Family -- Juliet Barker, c. 2010.

It is amazing how many books on the Brontës I've had in my library over the year! Most of them were given away to Arianna's high school literature teacher when I was forced to cull my library due to space limitations. I'm not sad I don't have those books any more but they do bring back wonderful memories. Especially some rare books found at the museum in Haworth. Now, everything is available on the internet.

Incredibly good book. Perhaps "the book" on the Brontës -- 979 pages with many "appendices."

Incredibly detailed.

Chapter One.
An Ambitious Man

Sizar;

"burning the candle at both ends" -- rush candles -- see YouTube on rush candles.

St Johns's at Cambridge.

 

1804: Napoleon. I think I need to read the bio of Napoleon -- though I've never been interested in Napoleon, for some reason.

Trafalgar.

Cambridge.

Breaks off engagement; Juliet Barker sorts this out in great detail.

Wellington, Shropshire, West Midlands, River Severn. At 220 miles, River Severn is the longest river in Great Britain.

p. 33: finally Yorkshire! Bradford. Sister cities, Bradford / Leeds -- I know the area well, having flown into Leeds when on temporary duty (TDY) to RAF Menwith Hill, Yorkshire, England.

p. 33: Martinique in the West Indies. Nice succinct history of the West Indies, passing from French to British control. Still a war zone. Abolition of slavery -- huge Evangelical issue. A huge issue for Patrick Brontë.

Martinique vs Yorkshire.

Chooses Yorkshire.

Chapter Two: The Promised Land (Yorkshire -- the Evangelicals considered Yorkshire "the Promised Land")

It's interesting: Haworth is only 57 minutes by car from Pateley Bridge and yet I only visited Haworth once as far I can recall. One of the most "amazing" and rewarding days I had in England during the latter years of my time. in the USAF. 

All the references to personal looms at home -- this is an important observation -- 1808 (early 1800s) -- think of Silas Marner by George Eliot, originally published, 1861, set in the "early years of the 19th century."

p. 38: "preach in the kitchen" like the Methodists, founder John Wesley (1703. 1791); tried to reform the Church of England from inside but ended up breaking away completely.

p. 41: missionary work in India.

p. 43: assizes: county courts

p. 43: "sentenced to transportation" for seven years -- exile for seven years -- less severe than a death penalty.

p. 44: box tombs -- google chest tombs -- Mrs Gaskell -- Haworth

p. 45: Robin Hood's grave in this area; Kirklees Priory, near Clifton / Hartshead villages southwest of Leeds, Haworth was 16 miles to the northwest, and northwest of Leeds

p. 46: 

Shirley, A Tale is an 1849 social novel by the English novelist Charlotte Brontë. It was Brontë's second published novel after Jane Eyre (originally published under Brontë's pseudonym Currer Bell). The novel is set in Yorkshire in 1811–12, during the industrial depression resulting from the Napoleonic Wars and the War of 1812. The novel is set against the backdrop of the Luddite uprisings in the Yorkshire textile industry.
The novel's popularity led to the surname Shirley becoming popular as a first name for women. Brontë tells the reader it was a tradition in the family to only give this surname as a first name to male children. It wasn't commonly used as a first name in England before the book. It is now regarded as a female first name. 

Much, much more at the wiki entry.

Again, a comparison of the Evangelicals (Brontë) with the Methodists. 

Many of the following pages are long passages regarding Patrick's religion and early writings.

The Luddites: p. 51. In response to the severe depression around 1812 -- machines taking jobs away from weavers. 

Remember, Silar Marner probably set in about 1805. 

First Luddite attacks in West Riding began in February, 1812, in the Huddersfield are, about six miles south of Hartshead. 

p. 54 -- Patrick now 35 y/o and ready to get married; story of Maria Branwell begins. Penzance, sea port. Wesleyan Conference split from Church of England in 1812.

Interesting: Penzance -- Chapel Street and Market Jew Street. "Jew Street"? -- p. 57.In fact the street name Market Jew Street derives from the Cornish 'Marghas Yow', which means Thursday Market. See this post: http://www.patrickcomerford.com/2019/10/cornwalls-jews-today-and-myths-about.html. Jane Austen writing mentioned p. 57, the social life in Penzance.

Then the letters from Maria Branwell, the mother of the Brontë sisters -- p. 59, they begin.

p. 63. Patrick and Maria get married -- 1812 -- quite a momentous year geo-politics. 

First child, first daughter, Maria Brontë born April 1814.

Second child, second daughter, Elizabeth Brontë born  February 8, 1815.

Patrick becomes curate of Thornton, a larger parish, that same year. Thornton, northwest of Hartshead, and midway between Hartshead and Haworth; directly west of Leeds.

Exact distance: "thirteen or so miles across Bradford" to their new home in Thornton.



 

Chapter Three
Good Neighbors and Kind Friends

Waterloo Day: June 18th.

Barker describes the desolation of the wild moors of Thornton in first pages of chapter three.

Strong tradition of "Nonconformity" in the area. p. 73.

Third daughter, third child, Charlotte -- p. 81.

Fourth child, first son, Patrick, born, June 26, 1817, p. 85. 

Fifth child, fourth daughter, July 30, 1818, born Emily Jane Brontë.

1819: Patrick, elder, offered position at Haworth. Long, long story.

17 January  1820: last child, a sixth child, a fifth daughter, born, Anne

Chapter Four
A Stranger in a Strange Land

Much taken from Live of Charlotte Brontë, Elizabeth Gaskell.

Gaskell considered Charlotte "her dear friend."

Opens with reception of three classic novels: Jane Eyre, Wuthering Heights, and The Tenant of Wildfell Hall. -- p 103.

Uses those texts to understand / describe Haworth at the time.

See middle paragraph p. 105.

Five miles from Thornton to Haworth.

I think had I known all this it would have been exciting to re-trace those steps from Hartshead to Thornton to Haworth over a period of five or six days, staying in pensions or inns or BnB's along the way with Pat.


***********************
**********************


Now that I've read this much, and have gotten a flavor of the book and having read much about the Brontës, I think I will now skip around and read the chapters that most interest me at the moment.

I will start now with the last chapters of the book, specifically, Chapter Twenty-Eight, The End of All, 1857 - 1861 & after -- the last chapter of the book, and then go back and read the chapters that might interest me. 

Already, I get melancholy, almost tearful, to think that the entirety of a most amazing family is held in these 979 pages, and that's it ... the life of two parents, and six children, in the cold, miserable moors of Yorkshire. 

The very first paragraph of the very first chapter of the book, begins:

"On the first day of October 1802 a twenty-five-year-old Irishman walked through the imposing gateway of St John's College, Cambridge. Tall and thin, with sandy red hair, his aristocratic features and bearing marked him out as one of the gentlemen of the university."

I picture Silas Marner and/or Rip Van Winkle looking much the same.

"His appearance was deceptive, however, for this young man had only recently arrived in England and had not yet embarked on a university career. Indeed, his purpose in coming to St Johns that day was to register as an undergraduate of the college."

And that's where it all began, although technically it would have begun twenty-five years earlier with his birth in Ireland.

But from his perspective think about it. He led a most challenging life in Yorkshire. All the challenges he would have faced.  

From wiki:

Patrick Brontë  born Patrick Brunty; 17 March 1777 – 7 June 1861) was an Irish Anglican minister and author who spent most of his adult life in England. He was the father of the writers Charlotte, Emily, and Anne Brontë, and of Branwell Brontë, his only son. Patrick outlived his wife, the former Maria Branwell, by forty years, by which time all of their six children had died as well. 

Not mentioned in that paragraph, the second of five daughters, Elizabeth, 1815 - 1825, who died of tuberculsis at age of ten. 

  • 1776: American Revolution
  • 1812: War of 1812; era of Napoleon
  • 1800s: Industrial Revolution
  • 1800s: abolitionist movement
  • 1861: US Civil War

Chapter Twenty-Eight, The End of All, 1857 - 1861 & after

Mrs Gaskell's Life of Charlotte Brontë: created a huge furor (I'll have to read about this later -- pp. 922 - 950).

Charlotte's first novel, The Professor, published after Gaskell's Life and Charlotte's novel almost overlooked.

A two-volume set released June, 1857.

Sales figures -- p. 955.

The Life put Haworth on the map, and not necessarily in a good way.

Martha Brown: at the parsonage in those years.

Sidgwicks of Stonegappe where Charlotte had once been a governess. p. 957.

Carrara marble, p. 959. Link here

Re-read the pages, 960 - 961 -- famous writers that went to Haworth after Gaskell's book came out after Charlotte died. 

Traduced: p. 965.

What is so much fun, the British words I've learned over the years. For example, p. 965, "When they arrived, having taken a fly from Keighley station .... "  A fly: a fast carriage designed for a single driver / passenger and a single horse. 

Patrick died June 7, 1861.

Ellen Nussey -- source of most information for Ms Gaskell. Ellen Nussey and Charlotte, classmates at Roe Head School. Lifelong friends, possibly lovers. Hundreds of letters exchanged.

Charlotte's husband bore the brunt of increasingly hysterical accusations.

Ellen Nussey, died at age 80, 1897.

It's really hard to sort this out ... Mrs Gaskell wrote a book of fiction ... that the myth has survived is a tribute to the emotive power of Mrs Gaskell's Life of Charlotte Brontë, which surely lives up to Patrick's expectation that it "will stand in the first rank, of Biographies, till the end of time." 

So, I guess this is it. The Brontës would have been as famous as George Eliot or Jane Austen -- in other words, hardly known at all -- had Gaskell's fiction not been written. So, in the end, Gaskell did the family a favor but probably put many through hell while they were living. And there it ended. Until people like Juliet Barker wrote an accurate biography of the family, but hardly as interesting.

I am sure that I probably never would have been as interested in the Brontës had it not been for Gaskell and her biography. And now it's hard to erase that book from my memory even after reading Barker's account. 

One needs to read wiki's account of Elizabeth Gaskell -- a well-known author for a short period -- knew a lot of writers, including Charles Dickens. But the wiki entry hardly mentions the Life of Charlotte. Patrick had asked Gaskell to write a biography of Charlotte, but knew she wouldn't be able to write a particularly accurate account. Too many stories and half-truths from those she interviewed. Many with their own agendas. On top of that, Ms Gaskell was a lifelong friend -- possibly a lover -- of Charlotte.

The good news, by reading Juliet Barker, I was able to connect some dots, perhaps come to closure with regard to the whole story. 

I think I would enjoy exploring Haworth one more time with Pat. It would be a bittersweet trip back to something that was beyond understanding.

Thursday, February 6, 2025

Tuesday, February 4, 2025

Paris: Secret Gardens, Hidden Places, and Stories of the City of Light, Mary McAuliffe, c. 2023.

Paris: Secret Gardens, Hidden Places, and Stories of the City of Light, Mary McAuliffe, c. 2023.

This really is a phenomenal book. Hardcover: around $25.

Twenty chapters. Each chapter is relatively short and covers one "area" of Paris.