Monday, November 16, 2026

Human Evolution, Robin Dunbar, c. 2016; reviewed in WSJ, Dec 31, 2016


 

November 16, 2026: The Ceprano calvarium (or Ceprano Man), discovered in southern Latium, Italy, in 1994, is a key transitional fossil bridging the gap between Homo erectus and later Middle Pleistocene hominins-like Homo heidelbergensis and Homo neanderthalensis. First noted by me in Ivetic's book on the Adriatic, c. 2022/2025, page 36.

Original Note 

Timeline from another book (Human Evolution, Robin Dunbar, c. 2016; reviewed in WSJ, Dec 31, 2016):

“Transitions” in human evolution:
2 million years ago: first transition that led to australopithecines (note: book below says 3.2 million years ago
1.8 mya: rise of early Homo 
0.5 mya: appearance of first archaic humans
0.2 mya: the rise of modern humans
0.012 mya: rise of Neolithic Age

OR in thousands of years:
2,000 thousand years ago: first transition that led to australopithecines
1,800 thousand years ago: rise of early Homo
500,000 years ago: appearance of first archaic humans
200,000 years ago: rise of modern humans
12,000 years ago: rise of Neolithic Age


Note, from wiki, re: Cro-Magnon:

Cro-Magnon =  modern human; earliest about 40,000 to 50,000 years ago
term falling out of usage
doesn’t refer to taxonomic static nor to an archaeological phase or culture
preferred term: European early modern human (EEMH)

From wiki, re: australopithecines:
several related species all under this one subtribe
extinct, close relatives of humans
with extant genus Homo comprise the human clade
members of the human clade, that is, the Hominini after the split from champanzees, are now called homonina

From wiki, re: hominidae:
members are known as the great apes, or hominids
taxonomic family of primates that include seven extant species in four genera:
Pongo (orangutan)
Gorilla
Pan (chimpanzee, and the bonobo)
Homo (human, and though not extant, the near-human ancestors and relatives, for example, the Neanderthal
It gets a bit confusing after this because meanings change, but according to wiki:
hominin has now overtaken “hominid”: comprises all members of the human clade after the split from Pan
current, 21st century meaning of “hominid’ refers to all the great apes, including humans
usage still varies; and some still use “hominid” in the usual, restrictive sense (“only humans”)



Australopithecus (Lucy): 3.2 million years ago

Note: Homo naledi may be 3,000,000 (3 million years old).

2.8 - 1.5 million years ago: Homo habilis

2.0 - 1.2 million years agp: Paranthropus robustus (also Australopithecus robustus); 

1.9 million years ago to 70,000 years ago: Homo erectus



The Neandertal Enigma: Solving the Mystery of Modern Human Origians, James Shreeve, c. 1995.

A difficult book to read. Author skips back and forth among different hypotheses; it’s as if it’s gonzo journalism reporting developments as they occur. 


Chapter 1:

Hominids around for 4 million years.

Cro-Magnon: five skeletons, south France; 30 - 32,000 years old; originally thought to be “modern humans” exhibiting first evidence of modern human behavior.

But, it was noted that human behavior was noted as long ago as 100,000 years ago. Originally thought human behavior accounted for “modern” human form — that is, human behavior drove the modernity of Cro-Magnon.

But modern human behavior noted as long ago as 100,000 years ago, and Cro-Magnon man only 30 - 32,000 years ago. Thus, Cro-Magnon man no longer synonymous with “modern man.”

James Shreeve cannot come up with any “new name” for modern humans, other than “modern human.”

The question Shreeve is asking: if modern human behavior is as old as 100,000 years, why did it take a “modern-looking man” to start developing human behavior 50,000 years to demonstrate that same behavior.

Based on his introductory comments (his love for Neanderthal); the need to sell a book; and, the subject matter of this book, one can almost guess where this is going.


The author says he’s a sucker for time-lines, and I don’t think there is one time-line in the book.

First hominid: Australopithecus aferensis (Lucy) (though in 1994, in Ethiopia reports of an earlier “hominid” very close to the split of ape and man).

Author questions the “truth” of the time lines. Starts with Leaky, then Johanson (Lucy). Lucy is described, perhaps 3.0 to 3.9 million years old, Ethiopia.

Hominids around for 4 million years; another split, 2 - 1.5 million years ago. Then out-of-Africa, maybe a 100,000 years ago, and Cro-Magnon, 32 to 30,000 years ago.

Homo erectus migration out of Africa is well documented, between one million and 700,000 years ago. (Some evidence, Java man, suggests as long ago as 2 million years ago.)

By 300,000 years ago, 

Chapter 1 ends with the various hominids (habilis, robustus, erectus).

Conventional thinking that everything evolved linearly (two parallel paths — one, to modern humans; the other alongside and died out). 

Now, modern thinking is that multiple hominid species lived side by side for millions of years.

This is setting the stage to prepare the reader for accepting the thesis that Neanderthals and modern humans lived side-by-side for thousands of years.

Chapter 2: Paraphrasing the thesis. By the time the modern human Africans started dispersing across the globe, they came into contact with non-African humans (Neandertals). The modern human Africans all trace their mtRNA back to Eve who is believed to have lived only 200,000 years ago — very, very young.

There appears to have been no intermingling between modern human Africans and the Neandertals because there is no non-African mtRNA and all mtRNA came from Eve (modern human Africa). It appears that modern anatomy appeared in Africa earlier than anywhere else (p. 69) but they did not take on human behavior until much later (later than Neandertals?).

Simplest explanation: Eve herself, or her descendants, had evolved into Homo sapiens sapiens before they left Africa. (p. 70)

This is huge. Anthropologists upset. This means Neandertals completely died out; no genes passed onto modern humans. Likewise, same with Java Man, Peking Man — simply died out; not in the evolutionary chain to modern humans.

Author spoke with Wallace, Stoneking, et al in Berkeley — proponents of Eve theory above.

Then author went to University of New Mexico to talke to Erik Trinkaus who disagrees (p. 71).

Then author meets with Milford Wolpoff, U of Michigan, and leading champion of the anti-Eve movement (this was back in 1995). 

Wolpoff bases his theory on fact that Chinese look like Chinese; original Australians look like original Australians, and Caucasians look like Neandertals, and that Caucasians evolved form Neandertals. 

Chapter 4: Arguments Over a Woman

Everyone agrees that modern humans developed from Homo erectus. The argument is when, where, how.

400,000 to 100,000 years ago: ambiguous clutter of bones that people have reluctantly agreed to call “archaic Homo sapiens.”


So the parallel paths: one path led to Neandertals; one led to Homo erectus and then Homo sapiens.

Neandertals: Homo sapiens neandertalis
Modern human: Homo sapiens sapiens

1971 — Stringer: felt Neandertals had been given a bum rap. But he could find now clear support for the idea of a Neadertal ancestral role in the evolution of modern Europeans; this was done by measuring and comparing skulls, not genetics.

Stringer viewed “African Neandertal” (Jebel Irhoud) — from the Moroccan coast. Stringer immediately felt it was not Neandertal at all, but closer to that of a modern human being than any other Neandertal he had ever seen. But the posterior skull looked more primitive than either Neandertal or modern human. [Wiki: 2007, determined to be modern human from 160,000 years ago.]

Ksar’ Akil (Egbert)

Stringer: supports the Out of Africa thesis even without Eve hypothesis.

Stringer vs Wolpoff. Stringer on side of most anthropologists. Wolpoff souncs like a crank.

Stringer’s view: Homo sapiens arose in only one place, Africa — and then later spread out, replacing all other archaic human populations. 

Current racial differences appeared very, very recently; within the last 20,000 years.

(Two migrations? Where did first begin? Iraq? and spread from there, globally — and then a second migration Out of Africa, replaying the first diaspora?)

Out of Africa, about 50,000 years ago.

“Thus, in Europe, it was Neandertals out, Cro-Magnons in, all at once, with no fossil forms showing a transition between them.” — p.87

Sounds like author doesn’t accept Wolpoff’s theory — the Wolpoff model — middle of page, p. 87.

It sounds like Wolpoff is a crank, mean, and trying to walk back his hypothesis (p. 89).

Author meets with Stringer again — p. 90.


Stringer’s main objective: to prove that Neandertals were not our ancestors — p. 91.

Bolstering his argument: recent modern human fossils in caves of Qafzeh and Skhul in Israel with ages around 100,000 years — thus pre-dating Neandertals — and thus obviously not descendants of Neandertals.

Cro-Magnon and Neandertal skulls side-by-side: huge difference.

Oldest European fossil known is an enigmatic jaw from near Heidelberg, Germany, believed to be about 500,000 years old. After that come some much more complete fossils of early archaic Homo sapiens, typified by the skull from Petralona in Greece, another from the French site of Arago, and just recently, by a magnificent new collection of skulls and other bones from Atapuerca in northern Spain — all of these date to about 300,000 years ago.

Those skulls seem to primitive to be Neandertal. Today, most investigators call them “pre-Neandertals.” They link up nicely with a group of early, true Neandertals beginning some 130,000 years ago and from there to a whole host of later ones scattered over the continent. So there appears to be gradual evolution in Europe, but not toward modern Europeans. And then Cro-Magnon Man makes an abrupt, audaciously modern appearance around 30,000 years ago. Stringer says the abruptness is not so evident in eastern Europe.

Stringer must prove that the two did not intermingle, and the change (loss of Neandertals) was fairly abrupt.

The African chain of evolution appears to be pretty solid — p. 94.  Broken Hill (Zambia, formerly part of Rhodesia) and Bodo (Ethiopia) — strikingly similar. Broken Hill’s contemporary was the Petralona skull from Greece; same is true of the Bodo skull. Appear to be erectus-like. In short, there is a credible bridge between erectus and the next link in the African chain toward modern humans.

Now, Jebel Irhoud: seems to be African transitional, where Neandertal went on a completely different pathway.

For Jebel Irhoud to be a transition between erectus and modern humans, the dates have to work.

Irhoud now thought to be 90,000 years old and possibly much older. Ngaloba is around 130,000 years old.

The story, then, for Out of Africa:

Somewhere about 130,000 years ago something happened in Africa that favored the evolution of modern-looking people. Between 130,000 and 100,000 years ago, these true human ancestors spread north and east from their homeland into the Levant (why?0, with perhaps another, separate population pushing south to establish the lineage of Klasies River Mouth and Border Cave. Whatever their reasons fro moving, when the northern-bound populations reached the Middle East, they appear to stop dead in their tracks (why?). After a delay of some 40,000 (lost in the desert) years, the moderns pushed out again, eventually replacing archaic populations everywhere else as well (by what power, to what advantage?). As they established their dominion in various parts of the world, they adapted to local conditions, giving rise to human races as we see today. — p. 96


The Out of Africa hypothesis (punctuated replacement) has difficult in China and seems to fall apart in Australia. 

Back to Wolpoff — the single species hypothesis.

In 1978, a change in his direction.

Richard Leakey’s find at Koobe Fora of a 1.5-million-year-old Homo erectus who must have lived at the same time as Australopithecus (Lucy). Wolpoff was shaken by this evidence but still believed in graduation evolution, not punctuated replacement. He still felt Neandertals were on the single pathway leading to modern humans.

The fossil that altered Wolpoff’s faith: Sangiran 17. Recent discovery. The most complete Homoe erectus skull yet discovered. Looked like a robust Australian aborigine. Wolpoff realized he was wrong.

End of chapter 4: Stringer’s Eve hypothesis seems to fall apart in China, Australia. Wolpoff’s regional evolution seems to have the upper hand.

Chapter 5:

It’s Stringer vs Wolpoff. Two models: total change or a measureless constancy.

Sangiran: the hulking erectus from Java.

Wolpoff / multiregional theory (p. 111): gene flow from region to region with interbreeding.

Many paleoanthropologists would settle for a scenario somewhere in between.

Somewhere it seems we’ve lost the nut of the argument: there is no Neandertal mitochondria in modern humans, I believe. It (mtRNA) all traces back to Eve. I could be wrong on this, but somehow the author has gotten me confused. How funny: just as I write that, at the bottom of page 113 I read this from the author: “then I remembered Eve.” He really is a poor writer, unless this is simply a journal taken directly from his notes.

And there it is, Wolpoff again (he seems to come off like a Luddite): “Our real quarrel is not with Chris Stringer. Our public enemy number one is Allan Wilson.”

What’s with all this “public enemy” talk. Why are not folks working together — take the data and discuss it in civil tones.

Finally, author is granted an interview with Allan Wilson at U of Berkeley.


From DNA, Allan Wilson: “Eve lived in Africa 142,000 years ago. We are all derivative of one of the !Kung lineages.”

A double shocker:

first: it meant that Eve was some 60,000 years younger than the already heretical 200,000 years  originally proposed;
second: she was a !Kung Bushman to boot

PCR discussed — invented in 1983 by Kary Mulflis of Cetus Corporation

Researchers study “a loop of mtDNA called the control region.” It doesn’t code for any proteins or other products; mutations there don’t affect the functioning of the molecule, so they can accumulate much faster.

A faster rate of mutations translates into a more accurate measurement of how much one person’s mtDNA type differs from another’s. Results revealed a phenomenal geographic coheasion. For example, Eastern and Western Pygmies of Central Africal — 1500 km apart — thought to be closely related — do not share one mitochondrial type between them.

Thanks to PCR, for the first time, human mtDNA can be compared directly with that of a chimpanzee. I did not know that.

Using that data, again everything traces back to African roots (p. 118).

Back to the human and chimp DNA clock — p. 119.

Almost everyone agrees that the apes split off from the hominid line between 5 and 7 million years ago.

Another researcher, using this clock, put Eve even closer to the present, 142,000 years ago.

Dating is still a problem. “We need more data from nuclear genes to really solve the problem.”

Wilson: it’s the anthropological perspective vs the genetic perspective.

Wilson: said Neandertals replaced because they could not speak. Okay. But went further: said they did not have a “speaking gene.”

Only the language-endowed African lineage would continue.

Mitochondrial genome affects functions of the nervous system; language is a function of the nervous system. Wilson doesn’t see this as outrageous. 

Wilson suggests Eve is as young as 120,000 years whereas Wolpoff and Fred Smith prefer to see Eve as a million years old. Huge discrepancy.

First important date: age of Eve.

Second important date: when Eve’s descendants first left Africa to populate the rest of the world.

They noticed a sudden rush of new branchings taking place about 60,000 years ago. Most likely explanation: rapid increase in population. “So the origins of Caucasians seem to correspond with the demise of the Neandertals,” Wilson observed. 

If data is correct, it suggests that human mitochondrial DNA is evolving at a faster rate than that of other species, which doesn’t make sense.

Leads to next question: what determines the rate of molecular evolution in the first place?

Wilson describes a positive feedback loop: where there is a gene that “listens” to the brain — there must be a mutation for the ability to “catch on.”

Almost sounds Lamarckian.

One year later, Allan Wilson died of acute leukemia.

**************

1990: Wolpoff calls again; inviting author to New Orleans where he will convinced that the Eve hypothesis is dead.

Geoffrey Long: research on cellular DNA where the real answers to modern origins are cached away — that’s what the author writes. Is that a correct assumption?

Geoffrey Long studies beta-globin gene.

Long: beta-globin suggests African origin, but can’t set time. He thinks the time was fairly recent.

Page 126: nerve canal in lower jaw suggests Cro-Magnon man got this trait from Neandertal.

Wolpoff seemed to be gaining.

Then, 1991, Science: Eve hypothesis gained new ground based on Linda Vigilant’s expanded study using PCR.

Author exhausted by genes and bones.

Halfway through the book, beginning with Chapter 6, he moves to human behavior.

Chapter 6: Welcome to the Stone Age

I skimmed through chapters 6 and 7, most of it talking about tools.

Chapter 8: A Sense Of Us

Neandertal and modern human lived side-by-side for 50,000 years.

Prior to modern human, anatomy and progress seemed to march hand-in-hand.

But when it came to modern human, anatomy seemed to get ahead of modern behavior.

The last Neandertal population dwindled to nothing about 30,000 years ago. At that time, the number of human species on earth thereafter was reduced to one. If anatomy cannot explain the demise of one, the success of the other, something else must explain it.

Chapter 9: A Matter of Time

Back to Stoneking and mtDNA. Eve appeared to have lived around 133,000 years ago; astonishingly young.

Jebel Irhoud, Morocco, once thought to be only 40,000 years old, is now pegged at 125,000 years old (similar to Eve).

The nearly modern Omo skull from Ethiopia is around 130,000 years old.

The Ngaloba skull (laetoli 18, Tanzania), is about the same age.

Bottom line: the age of the common mitochondrial mother (Eve) and the age of the transitional African fossils — no longer totally archaic, but yet not fully modern — seem to coincide. 

Agreement between bones and genes: 130,000 years ago. Glacial cycle, Stage 6, reached its coldest extreme at that same time.

Africans would not have noticed; far north Neandertals would have been freezing.

Leaning on its big brain, the Homo lineage had endured a dozen ice ages before Stage 6, with only morphological shift grand enough to be deemed a clear species break. This was the evolution of Homo habilis-like hominids into Homo erectus some 1.5 million years ago, an event marked by, among many other traits, enormous increases in brain and body size. The emergence of modern anatomy was not so dramatic a change.

75,000 years ago: devastating Toba volcanic eruption.

Chapter 10: How Do You Make A Modern?

Likely that near-modern evolved in Africa. Then about 50,000 years ago, a breakthrough occurred in this African lineage, a neurological change that allowed them to develop all these new cultural behaviors. It could just as well have happened to the Neandertals instead, but it didn’t.

In other words, the Upper Paleolithic did not happen before 40,000 years ago because there were no brains around developed enough to make it happen. 

Looking for evidence that a neurological change in a discrete population of moderns was responsible for the Upper Paleolithic — one would expect the whole behavioral package — the art, the new tools, and so on — to begin in one geographic location and spread out, as the moderns moved into new territories. BUT, no such patter can be seen, even in Europe, where most of the looking has gone on.

Modernity moved at different times. The Middle East is the last area where art appears, even though it is the first where people began to rely on blade tools. In Eastern Europe, fully modern-looking fossils turn up thousands of years before any Upper Paleolithic artifacts. Furthermore, at the end of the Upper Paleolithic, around 12,000 years ago, all the restless creativity of the landscape seems to quiet down.

In many ways, the Mesolithic Period that followed was relatively unoriginal, culturally speaking.

Back to language. The hyoid.

Chapter 11: Double Wisdom (Homo sapiens sapiens)

















































No comments:

Post a Comment